SENATE
JOURNAL #1
CONVENING DAY
January 8, 2003
The Senate met at 10:00 a.m.
A quorum was present.
The Reverend David P. Jones, Chaplain to the Senate, offered the prayer.
Here we are, Lord - Senators, staff members, lobbyists, members of the media, school children and people who have just come to watch. As we all fasten our seat belts and get ready for this beginning, we ask you to make our leaders firm, flexible, wise, open, smart, humble and humorous, that, at the end of the day, what you have in mind is what they come to decide. Amen
Senator Gallus led the Pledge of Allegiance.
INTRODUCTION OF STAFF
PRESIDENT'S STAFF
Amy Ireland Bourgault, Chief of Staff
Donna L. Morin, Executive Assistant
Nancy L. Nolin, Secretary
Carole A. Paling, Special Assistant
Franklin G. Torr, Budget Director to the Senate President
LEGAL COUNSEL
Richard J. Lehmann
REPUBLICAN LEADERSHIP STAFF
Jay W. Flanders, Majority Policy Director
MINORITY LEADERSHIP STAFF
Margaret A. Fitz, Secretary
Marlene D. Taylor, Executive Secretary
Communications Director
Deborah A. Bradley
SENATE CLERK'S STAFF
Ann Marie Daniels, Calendar Clerk
Edward R. Hebert, Status Information Technician
Brenda L. Mento, Journal Clerk
Malcolm A. Richards, Senate Recorder
LEGISLATIVE AIDES
Susan F. Duncan, Senior Legislative Aide
Joshua R. Chamberlain
Angela J. Spradling
Kristy Stuart
COMMITTEE SECRETARIES:
Livia Acdan
Susan A. Bridge
L. Gail Brown
Carlene C. Cayes
Merideth A. Chandler
Michelle L. Doucette
Gloria C. Lamoureux
Pamela J. Manocchi
SENATE RESEARCH
June C. Goulson, Director
Elaine D. Rapp, Senior Research Assistant
Diana M. Ferguson, Research Assistant
Theresa D. Neves, Administrative Research Assistant
CORRESPONDANCE SECERETARY
Meredith L. Warren
SENATE INTERNS
Emily Cole
Dan Dussault
Melissa Lawler
Beau Robinson
INTRODUCTION OF GUESTS
NOMINATIONS
Nominations for Senate Doorkeeper.
Senator Flanders moved that the name of John J. Byrnes, Sr., be placed in nomination for Senate Doorkeeper.
Senator O'Hearn seconded the motion.
Further nominations.
Senator Flanders moved that the nominations be closed and that one ballot be cast for John J. Byrnes, Sr., for Senate Doorkeeper.
Adopted.
John J. Byrnes, Sr., is elected Senate Doorkeeper.
Senator Gallus escorted John J. Byrnes, Sr., to the rostrum.
The President administered the oath of office to the Senate Doorkeeper.
HOUSE MESSAGE
The House of Representatives is ready to meet in Joint Session for the purpose of canvassing the votes for Governor and Executive Council and for taking of the oath for the State Treasurer.
RESOLUTION
Senator Johnson moved that the Senate be in Joint Convention for the purpose of canvassing the votes for Governor and Executive Council and the swearing in of the State Treasurer.
Adopted.
In recess for Joint Convention.
Out of recess.
SENATE RULES
Senator Green moved that the Senate adopt the Senate Rules as amended and approved by the Committee on Rules and Enrolled Bills on January 2, 2003.
Senator Clegg moved that Senate Rule 14 be amended to read as follows:
No vote shall be reconsidered, unless the motion for reconsideration be made by a member who voted with the prevailing side. The notice of such motion for reconsideration shall be given to the Senate in open session prior to adjournment on the same day on which the vote as passed, or to the clerk within 2 working business days of the vote. Any such notice of reconsideration shall be effective for three legislative days only and thereafter shall be null and void. Reconsideration of any bills subject to a transfer date established by Senate joint rules must be acted upon on or before the Senate joint rule deadline, and thereafter shall be null and void.
and that Senate Rule 18 (c) be amended to read as follows:
(c) Filing period for legislation to be acted on in the second half of the biennium, beginning January 2004 2002, will commence on Monday, October 20, 2003 April 16, 2001. The office of legislative services shall not draft a senate bill or joint resolution, unless a request by a member for drafting with complete information has been received not later than 3:00 p.m., Friday, November 14, 2003 April 20, 2001. Last day to sign-off legislation for the January 2004 2002 session shall be Friday December 19, 2003 August 1, 2001, at 3:00 p.m.
Amendment adopted.
Senator Below moved that Senate Rule 33 be amended to read as follows:
No person except members of the Senate and its officers, the Governor members of the executive, Council members, the Secretary of State, the Treasurer, or the Speaker of the House of Representatives and its officers and clerks, shall be admitted to the floor of the Senate while the Senate is in session, except by the invitation of the President, or some member with the President’s his consent.
Amendment adopted.
Question is on the adoption of the 2003-2004 Senate Rules.
Adopted.
INTRODUCTION OF SENATE BILLS
Senator Clegg moved that in accordance with the list in the possession of the Senate Clerk, Senate Bills numbered 11 to 21 inclusive shall be by this resolution read a first and second time by the therein listed titles.
Adopted.
First and Second Reading and Referral
03-0120
SB 11-FN, establishing new special justice positions in the Manchester, Concord, and Nashua district courts. (O'Hearn, Dist 12; Larsen, Dist 15; Hager, Merr 40; Judiciary)
03-0157
SB 12-FN-A-LOCAL, establishing a property tax relief program for low income homeowners. (Peterson, Dist 11; Flanders, Dist 7; M. Carter, Hills 44; Ways and Means)
03-0272
SB 13, relative to judicially appointed officials. (Boyce, Dist 4; Soltani, Merr 37; Judiciary)
03-0273
SB 14, relative to vacancies in county offices. (Boyce, Dist 4; Flanders, Dist 7; Leber, Merr 35; E. Smith, Ches 26; Emerton, Hills 48; Internal Affairs)
03-0275
SB 15, relative to election day registration. (Boyce, Dist 4; Alger, Graf 14; Dudley, Graf 18; Internal Affairs)
03-0276
SB 16-FN, establishing a state employee recognition and award program. (Boyce, Dist 4; O'Hearn, Dist 12; McHugh, Hills 61; Executive Departments and Administration)
03-0277
SB 17, relative to incompatible offices. (Boyce, Dist 4; Bruno, Hills 45; Internal Affairs)
03-0289
SB 18-FN, relative to vehicle stops at railroad grade crossings. (Barnes, Dist 17; Bishop, Rock 74; D. Smith, Rock 74; Weldy, Rock 74; Transportation)
03-0293
SB 19-FN, relative to notification of groundwater contamination and repealing certain MTBE notification requirements for public water systems. (Prescott, Dist 23; Letourneau, Rock 77; Environment)
03-0454
SB 20, relative to the qualifications for the property tax exemption for the disabled. (Barnes, Dist 17; Bishop, Rock 74; D. Smith, Rock 74; Weldy, Rock 74; Public Affairs)
03-0603
SB 21, relative to health insurance riders. (Flanders, Dist 7; Prescott, Dist 23; Insurance)
RESOLUTION
Senator Larsen moved that the Senate now adjourn from the early session, that the business of the late session be in order at the present time and that when we adjourn, we adjourn to January 9, 2003 at 11:00 a.m.
Adopted.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
Senator Eaton Rule #44.
LATE SESSION
Senator Clegg moved that the Senate adjourn until Thursday, January 9, 2003 at 11:00 a.m.
Adopted.
Adjournment.
RULES OF THE SENATE
|
1. |
The President, having taken the chair, shall determine a quorum to be present. Any erroneous entry in the daily journal shall be corrected no later than the third succeeding legislative day, and the permanent journal corrected within one week after the permanent journal copy is placed in the hands of the Senate. |
|
2. |
No member shall hold conversation with another while a member is speaking in debate, or use electronic devices, including but not limited to personal computers, and telephonic devices, without leave of the Senate. |
|
3. |
Every member, wishing to speak, shall notify the President. When the member is recognized to speak he shall rise and address the President, and when he has finished shall then sit down. |
|
4. |
No member shall speak more than twice on the same question on the same day without leave of the Senate President. |
|
5. |
More than one member wishing to speak at the same time, the President shall decide who shall speak first. |
|
6. |
The President shall preserve decorum and order. If any member transgresses the rules of the Senate, the President shall, or any member may, call him to order in which case the member so called to order shall immediately cease and desist, and the Senate, if appealed to, shall decide the case. But if there is no appeal, the decision of the President shall be conclusive. |
|
7. |
No member shall absent himself without permission from the Senate. |
|
8. |
When any question is under debate, no motion shall be received but first, to adjourn; second, to lay upon the table; third, for the previous question; fourth, to postpone to a certain day; fifth, to commit; sixth, to amend; and seventh, to postpone indefinitely; which several motions shall have precedence in the order in which they are so arranged. Motions to adjourn, to lay upon the table, for the previous question, and to take from the table shall be decided without debate. Motions to postpone to a certain day shall be debatable both as to time and subject matter. No motion to postpone indefinitely, to postpone to a certain day, or to commit, being decided, shall be in order at the same stage of the bill or resolution, until after adjournment. |
|
9. |
A question which is postponed indefinitely shall not be acted upon during the biennium except whenever two-thirds of the whole number of elected Senators shall on division taken, vote in favor thereof. Any bill which is indefinitely postponed shall not be reintroduced under cover of an amendment any bill, resolution, order, or committee of conference report. No motion to suspend this rule shall be permitted. |
|
10. |
Any member may call for a division of the question when the sense will admit it. Unless otherwise specifically provided for, a majority of those present and voting shall be required to pass any vote. |
|
11. |
When the reading of a paper or document is objected to by a member, the question shall be determined by a vote of the Senate; and without debate. |
|
12. |
When the nays and yeas have been moved by a member and duly seconded by another member each member present shall declare his assent or dissent to the question, unless for special reason he be excused by the Senate. The names of the persons so making the motion and the second shall be recorded in the Journal. The President shall determine the order of the roll call. No member shall be required to vote in any case where he was not present when the question was put. |
|
13. |
In case of any disturbance or disorderly conduct in the gallery, the President shall have the power to order the same to be cleared. The Chairman of the Committee of the Whole may restrict attendance to the duly elected Senators. |
|
14. |
No vote shall be reconsidered, unless the motion for reconsideration be made by a member who voted with the prevailing side. The notice of such motion for reconsideration shall be given to the Senate in open session prior to adjournment on the same day on which the vote as passed, or to the clerk within 2 working business days of the vote. Any such notice of reconsideration shall be effective for three legislative days only and thereafter shall be null and void. Reconsideration of any bills subject to a transfer date established by Senate rules must be acted upon on or before the Senate rule deadline, and thereafter shall be null and void. |
|
15. |
Before any petition shall be received and read, a brief statement of the contents thereof shall be made by the member introducing the same. |
|
16. |
All petitions, memorials and other papers addressed to the Senate and all bills and resolutions to be introduced in the Senate, shall be endorsed with the name of the Senator presenting them, and with the subject matter of the same. Every bill shall be marked on the first page "Senate Bill" and numbered serially; every joint resolution shall be marked "Senate Joint Resolution" and numbered serially; every concurrent resolution proposing a constitutional amendment shall be marked "Concurrent Resolution Proposing a Constitutional Amendment" and numbered serially; and every other concurrent resolution shall be marked "Senate Concurrent Resolution" and numbered serially, as each bill or resolution is introduced into the Senate. |
|
17. |
All petitions, memorials and other papers addressed to the Senate and all bills and resolutions to be introduced into the Senate shall be delivered or caused to be delivered to the Office of Legislative Services, which in turn will submit it to the sponsor for his signature, and then to the Clerk by Legislative Services. If requested by the sponsor, a proposed bill, resolution or petition shall not be made public, except by the sponsor, until signed by the sponsor. During any adjournment the President may receive bills and resolutions for printing and for reference to committee, provided that no bill shall have a public hearing until it is formally introduced into the Senate printed and available for distribution. The President shall take up all bills and resolutions for introduction at the early session. |
|
18. |
Drafting of Bills |
|
(a) The Office of Legislative Services shall not draft a Senate bill or resolution, other than the general appropriations (budget) bill or the capital budget bill, unless a request by a member for drafting with complete information has been received not later than 3:00 p.m. on Friday, December 20, 2002. |
|
|
(b) Every Senate bill and joint resolution, except the general appropriations (budget) bill or the capital budget bill, must be signed off in Legislative Services by 3:00 p.m., on Friday, January 24, 2003. The last day to act on all Senate bills in the first body is April 10, 2003. |
|
|
(c) Filing period for legislation to be acted on in the second half of the biennium, beginning January 2004, will commence on Monday, October 20, 2003. The office of legislative services shall not draft a senate bill or joint resolution, unless a request by a member for drafting with complete information has been received not later than 3:00 p.m., Friday, November 14, 2003. Last day to sign-off legislation for the January 2004 session shall be Friday, December 19, 2003, at 3:00 p.m. |
|
|
(d) If a drafting request for a bill or resolution has been filed with the office of Legislative Services requiring a fiscal note as provided in RSA 14:44-47, the substance or a draft of the proposal may be provided to the legislative budget assistant for preparation of the required fiscal note without the specific consent of the sponsor of the proposal, provided that the identity of the sponsor shall not be disclosed. |
|
|
(e) Notwithstanding the provisions of 17 (a), (b), and (c), a Senate bill, Senate joint resolutions, or Senate concurrent resolution may be accepted by Legislative Services for drafting and introduced into the Senate at any time prior to the deadline established by Senate Rules for the transfer of bills out of the first body if approved by either a majority of the Senate Rules Committee or a two-thirds vote on the floor. |
|
|
(f) No bill the subject matter of which has been indefinitely postponed or made inexpedient to legislate in the Senate in the first-year session shall be admitted into the second-year session whether as a bill, an amendment, a committee of conference report or in any other manner. |
|
|
(g) Legislation returned from the non-originating body, with an amendment, shall not be re-referred to Committee but shall have one of the following recommendations: Concur, Nonconcur, Nonconcur and Request a Committee of Conference. Adoption of a motion to Nonconcur kills the legislation. |
|
|
19. |
Committees of Conference. |
|
(a) Whenever there be any disagreement between the Senate and the House on the content of any bill or resolution, and whenever both bodies, voting separately, have agreed to establish a committee of conference, the President of the Senate shall appoint three members to the Senate conference committee on the bill and the Speaker of the House shall appoint four members to the House conference committee. Exceptions: (1) the House committee of conference on the operating budget shall consist of five members; (2) the number of the members of the committees of conference on any bill may increase or decrease if the President and the Speaker both agree. The two committees of conference on a bill shall meet jointly but vote separately while in conference. A unanimous vote by both committees of conference shall be necessary for an agreed report to the Senate and the House by the committees of conference. |
|
|
(b) The first-named person from the body where the bill or resolution in disagreement originated shall have the authority to call the time and place for the first meeting of the committees of conference on said bill. |
|
|
(c) The first-named person on a committee of conference shall be the chairman of that conference. The chairman of the committee of conference of the body where the bill or resolution in disagreement originated shall chair the joint meeting of the committees of conference. |
|
|
(d) No action shall be taken in either body on any committee of conference report earlier than some subsequent day, after the report has been delivered to the seats or placed on a member's desk. A committee of conference may neither change the title of any bill submitted to it nor add amendments which are not germane to the subject matter of the bill as originally submitted to it. |
|
|
(e) Conference Committees on Budget Bills. The report of each committee of conference on either the general appropriation bill, or the capital improvements bill shall be printed in the journal or a supplement thereto of the appropriate body before action on said report is taken on the floor. Non-germane amendments, sections and footnotes to such bills (except footnotes in explanation of the principal text of such bills or designating the use or restriction of any funds or portions thereof) are prohibited and shall not be allowed under any circumstances. Notwithstanding the general provisions of paragraph (h) of this section, the Conference Committee on general appropriations bill may propose new items for inclusion in said bill but no such item may be so included unless and until it shall have been returned to both the Senate and the House and adopted in identical form by a majority vote in each body. |
|
|
(f) When both committees of conference on a concurrent resolution proposing an amendment to the constitution have agreed, the committee of conference from the body which acceded to a request for committees of conference shall file its report with the clerk of that body who shall print it in full in the journal or supplement of that body. The report shall be made a special order of business at the late session of a subsequent day. After said report has been adopted by the first body, a message shall be transmitted to the second body which shall then act upon the report of its committee of conference. |
|
|
(g) The sponsor of any bill or joint resolution referred to committees of conference shall, upon his request, be granted a hearing before said committees prior to action thereon. |
|
|
(h) No member of a committee of conference shall sign any report that contains non-germane amendments or subject matter that has been indefinitely postponed in either body. For the purposes of this rule, a non-germane amendment would be any subject matter not contained in either the House or the Senate version of the bill. |
|
|
(i) The deadline for Committee of Conference report sign-off is June 18, 2003 at 3:00 p.m. |
|
|
20. |
All resolutions which may require the signature of the Governor shall be treated in the same manner as bills. |
|
21. |
Every bill shall have three readings in the Senate previous to its passage. The first and second readings shall be by title only which may be accomplished by a conglomerate resolution, after which the bill shall be referred by the President to the appropriate committee and shall be printed as provided in Rule 22, unless otherwise ordered by the Senate. No bill after it has been read a second time shall have a third reading until after adjournment from the early session. The time assigned for the third reading of bills and resolutions shall be in the late session unless otherwise ordered by the Senate. The orders of the day for the reading of bills shall hold for every succeeding day until disposed of. |
|
22. |
After every bill shall have been read a second time, and referred by the President to the appropriate committee, the Clerk shall procure a sufficient number of copies, printed on paper of uniform size, for the use of the legislature, and cause the same to be distributed to the members, and when printed the bill shall be immediately delivered to the committee to which it shall have been referred. Bills received from the House shall be printed at the same stage of their procedure unless they have been printed in the House and copies distributed in the Senate, in which case any amendment made by the House shall be duplicated and distributed in the Senate. |
|
23. |
No amendment shall be made but upon the second reading of a bill; and all amendments to bills and resolutions shall be in writing, with the name of the Senator and the district he represents, or in the case of a committee amendment the name of the committee that recommended it, thereon. No amendment to any bill shall be proposed or allowed at any time or by any source, including a committee of conference, except it be germane. Amendments shall have been reviewed by the Office of Legislative Services for form, construction, statutory and chapter reference. |
|
24. |
A hearing shall be held upon each bill referred to a committee, and notice of such hearing shall be advertised at least 5 days before hearing in the Senate Calendar. The Senate Calendar shall be available on the Internet for viewing as soon as it has been released for printing. |
|
(a) All bills in the possession of committees shall be reported out with one of the following recommendations: ought to pass, ought to pass with amendment, re-refer to committee, inexpedient to legislate, or refer for interim study. Refer for interim study shall be a committee report only in the second year. |
|
|
(b) Any legislation creating a chapter study committee shall have membership limited to members of the General Court. |
|
|
25. |
When a bill is reported favorably with an amendment, the report of the committee shall state the amendment, and then recite the section of the bill in full as amended. The amendment shall be printed in the calendar of the Journal on the date that the report is listed for action. If no action is taken on that day, then the amendment shall be printed on the day to which the bill has been referred. All bills reported shall be retained by the clerk and shall not be finally acted upon until the following legislative day, and a list of such bills with the report thereon shall be published in the Journal for the day on which action shall be taken. |
|
26. |
Every bill and joint resolution appropriating money, which has been referred to another committee and favorably accepted by the Senate, shall be committed to the Finance Committee for review. If any such bills have been referred jointly to the Finance Committee and another standing committee, the Finance Committee may report separately and a further public hearing may be held at the discretion of the Finance Committee. All bills appropriating money, which are referred directly to the Finance Committee shall have a hearing. |
|
27. |
All warrants, subpoenas and other processes issued by order of the Senate shall be under the hand and seal of the President attested by the Clerk. |
|
28. |
All committees of the Senate, including Senate members on committees of conference, shall consist of members of both parties as nearly equal as possible, provided that on all committees, both parties shall be represented. The President shall appoint the members of all committees, after consulting with the minority leader. |
|
29. |
The standing committees of the Senate shall be as follows: The Committee on Finance, Committee on Capital Budget, Committee on Ways & Means, Committee on Banks, Committee on (present Economic Development) Energy and Economic Development, Committee on Education, Committee on Environment, Committee on Executive Departments & Administration, Committee on Wildlife & Recreation, Committee on Insurance, Committee on Internal Affairs, Committee on Interstate Cooperation, Committee on Judiciary, Committee on Public Affairs, Committee on Public Institutions Health & Human Services, Committee on Rules & Enrolled Bills, and the Committee on Transportation. |
|
30. |
Messages shall be sent to the House of Representatives by the Clerk of the Senate. |
|
31. |
Messages from the Governor or House of Representatives may be received at all times, except when the Senate is engaged in putting the question, in calling the yeas and nays, or in counting the ballots. |
|
32. |
All questions shall be put by the President, and each member of the Senate present shall signify his assent or dissent by voting yea or nay, or shall abstain from voting by reason of a conflict pursuant to rule 42. If the President doubts, or a division is called for, the Senate shall divide. Those in the affirmative on the question shall first rise from their seats and stand until they be counted. The President shall rise and state the decision of the Senate. |
|
33. |
No person except members of the Senate and its officers, the Governor, Council members, the Secretary of State, the Treasurer, the Speaker of the House of Representatives and its officers and clerks, shall be admitted to the floor of the Senate while the Senate is in session, except by the invitation of the President, or some member with the President’s consent.
|
|
34. |
The Senate shall adjourn to meet on the subsequent legislative day for the early session at the time mentioned in the adjournment motion. The late session shall immediately follow the early session unless the Senate shall otherwise order. |
|
35. |
No standing rule of the Senate shall be suspended unless two-thirds of the members present and voting vote in favor thereof. This rule shall not apply to Senate Rule 9. |
|
36. |
No rule shall be rescinded unless two days notice of the motion has been given and two-thirds of those present and voting vote therefore. |
|
37. |
The Senate may resolve itself into a Committee of the Whole at any time on motion made for that purpose; and in forming a Committee of the Whole, the President shall leave the chair, and appoint a chairperson to preside in committee. |
|
38. |
The President when performing the duties of the Chair may, at any time, name any member to perform the duties of the Chair. |
|
39. |
The staff of the Senate shall be comprised of a clerk, an assistant clerk, a sergeant-at-arms, and a doorkeeper who are to be elected by the Senate, and such other personnel as the President shall appoint. The President shall define the duties of all members of the Senate staff which are not fixed by statute or otherwise ordered by the Senate. |
|
40. |
Each member of the staff of the Senate shall be available on call to carry out the work of the Senate. |
|
41. |
The committees shall promptly consider and report on all matters referred to them. The President may authorize such committees having a heavy load of investigation, re-drafting, research or amendments to meet as needed on non-legislative days during the legislative session. The Clerk of the Senate shall prepare a list by number, title and sponsor of all Senate bills and resolutions in committee which have not been acted upon within one week before the deadline established for the transfer of bills and resolutions from the Senate to the House of Representatives, and he/she shall distribute this list to every member of the Senate as soon as it is prepared. |
|
42. |
In all instances every member shall act in conformance with the duly adopted Ethical Guidelines and Opinions of the New Hampshire General Court. |
|
43. |
Action on the floor of a report of the Committee on Finance or a Committee of Conference on either the general appropriations (budget) bill or the capital budget bill, shall not be taken by the Senate, until said report has been available from the Senate Clerk twenty-four hours in advance, in written form. Nongermane amendments and footnotes to such bills (except footnotes in explanation of the principal text of such bills or designating the use or restriction of any funds or portions thereof) are prohibited and shall not be allowed under any circumstances. |
|
44. |
PERSONAL PRIVILEGE: A Senator may, as a matter of personal privilege, defend his/her position on a bill, his/her integrity, his/her record, or his/her conduct, against unfair or unwarranted criticism, or may speak of an issue which relates to his/her rights, privileges or conveniences as a Senator; provided, however, the matters raised under personal privilege shall not be subject to questioning, answer, or debate, by another Senator. Personal Privilege remarks may be included in the Daily Journal if requested by the Senator, and in the Permanent Journal by vote of the Senate. A Senator may speak on other matters of his/her choosing and in such cases may be subject to questioning and/or answer according to the Rules of the Senate. |
|
45. |
Any appeal from the ruling of the presiding officer shall be decided by majority vote of the members present and voting. |
|
46. |
No new motion shall be admitted under color of amendment as a substitute for the motion under debate. |
|
47. |
No officer or employee of the Senate during the session or any adjournment thereof shall purchase or contract for the purchase, pay or promise to pay any sum of money on behalf of the Senate or issue any requisition or manifest without the approval of the Senate President. |